Show these hotels on a Map   Shelter Island Hotels on a Map

The closest you can book a hotel is 3.5 mi. from Shelter Island in Southold Take a look on the Map

starstarstar
Shelter Island New York Hotels - Sound View Greenport
Rating
9.4
mode_comment Wonderful
Sound View Greenport
58775 Route 48
Southold, NY 11944
accessible Accessible   pets Pets Allowed   local_dining Restaurant   golf_course Golf   room_service Room Service
3.5 mi. from Shelter Island | Map 
Book Now
starstarstarstar
Shelter Island New York Hotels - Baron's Cove
Rating
7.0
mode_comment Good
Baron's Cove
31 W. Water Street
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
business_center Business Center   airport_shuttle Free Airport Shuttle   wifi Free Internet Available   fitness_center Fitness Center or Spa   local_parkingFree Parking   accessible Accessible   smoke_free No Smoking Rooms/Facilities   local_dining Restaurant   pool Swimming Pool   room_service Room Service
5.1 mi. from Shelter Island | Map 
Book Now
starstarstar
Shelter Island New York Hotels - Southampton Inn
Rating
8.8
mode_comment Excellent
Southampton Inn
91 Hill Street
Southampton, NY 11968
business_center Business Center   wifi Free Internet Available   fitness_center Fitness Center or Spa   local_parkingFree Parking   accessible Accessible   smoke_free No Smoking Rooms/Facilities   pets Pets Allowed   local_dining Restaurant   pool Swimming Pool   golf_course Golf   room_service Room Service
13.1 mi. from Shelter Island | Map 
Book Now
starstarstar
Shelter Island New York Hotels - The Atlantic
Rating
0.0
mode_comment Very Poor
The Atlantic
1655 County Road 39
Tuckahoe, NY
business_center Business Center   accessible Accessible   pets Pets Allowed   pool Swimming Pool  
13.3 mi. from Shelter Island | Map 
Book Now
starstarstarstar
Shelter Island New York Hotels - Saybrook Point Resort & Marina
Rating
10.0
mode_comment Exceptional
Saybrook Point Resort & Marina
Two Bridge Street
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
accessible Accessible   local_dining Restaurant   local_laundry_service Laundry   room_service Room Service
14.9 mi. from Shelter Island | Map 
Book Now
starstarstarstar_half
Shelter Island New York Hotels - Water's Edge Resort & Spa
Rating
9.2
mode_comment Wonderful
Water's Edge Resort & Spa
1525 Boston Post Road
Westbrook, CT 06498
business_center Business Center   wifi Free Internet Available   fitness_center Fitness Center or Spa   local_parkingFree Parking   accessible Accessible   smoke_free No Smoking Rooms/Facilities   local_dining Restaurant   pool Swimming Pool   local_laundry_service Laundry   golf_course Golf   room_service Room Service
15.5 mi. from Shelter Island | Map 
Book Now
starstar
Shelter Island New York Hotels - PIER BLUE INN Old Saybrook - Essex
Rating
4.4
mode_comment Disappointing
PIER BLUE INN Old Saybrook - Essex
1430 Boston Post Road
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
business_center Business Center   wifi Free Internet Available   accessible Accessible   smoke_free No Smoking Rooms/Facilities   pets Pets Allowed   local_laundry_service Laundry  
15.5 mi. from Shelter Island | Map 
Book Now
starstar
Shelter Island New York Hotels - PIER BLUE INN Old Saybrook - Essex
Rating
9.0
mode_comment Wonderful
PIER BLUE INN Old Saybrook - Essex
1430 Boston Post Road
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
business_center Business Center   wifi Free Internet Available   local_parkingFree Parking   accessible Accessible   smoke_free No Smoking Rooms/Facilities   pets Pets Allowed  
15.5 mi. from Shelter Island | Map 
Book Now
starstar
Shelter Island New York Hotels - Econo Lodge Inn And Suites Old Saybrook
Rating
5.4
mode_comment Fair
Econo Lodge Inn and Suites Old Saybrook
1750 Boston Post Road
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
free_breakfast Free Breakfast    business_center Business Center   wifi Free Internet Available   fitness_center Fitness Center or Spa   local_parkingFree Parking   accessible Accessible   smoke_free No Smoking Rooms/Facilities   pets Pets Allowed   pool Swimming Pool   local_laundry_service Laundry   golf_course Golf   room_service Room Service
15.6 mi. from Shelter Island | Map 
Book Now
starstar
Shelter Island New York Hotels - Super Eight Motel-Old Saybrook
Rating
0.0
mode_comment Very Poor
Super Eight Motel-Old Saybrook
37 Spencer Plain Rd, Old Saybrook, Ct 06475, Usa
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
15.8 mi. from Shelter Island | Map 
Book Now
More Hotels  

SaveOnHotels.com is the easiest way to help you find the best savings on hotels in Shelter Island, New York.

You can compare all of the Shelter Island hotel rooms including the major Shelter Island hotel chains using our unique guest rating system as well as Shelter Island hotel reviews to help find the perfect hotel room when booking your accommodation in Shelter Island, New York.

Why use SaveOnHotels.com to book your Shelter Island lodging & accommodation?

We can help you to find the perfect Shelter Island hotel room for almost any occaision. Using our fast hotel search you will be able to compare different Shelter Island hotels by:

  • Locations within Shelter Island
  • Neighborhoods in Shelter Island
  • Nearby Shelter Island attractions
  • Hotels in nearby Shelter Island cities
  • Hotels in different areas of New York
  • By promotional rates
  • Price
  • Star rating
  • Amenities
  • Hotel name & chain

For hotels in Shelter Island, New York we provide:

  • Up to the minute hotel rates & availability
  • Detailed hotel information and photos
  • Comprehensive Shelter Island maps showing the locations of hotels in Shelter Island and the nearest transportation and landmarks
  • Save On Hotels Shelter Island hotel ratings

When you make a hotel reservation in Shelter Island with Save On Hotels we'll send you email confirmations with the reservation details of your hotel booking along with hotel contact details, directions, information on nearby Shelter Island attractions, and if you get stuck, we're only a phone call away.

To make the most of our service, check back frequently to view up to the minute Shelter Island hotel savings.

Shelter Island, New York Hotels. Hotels in Shelter Island. Hotels in Shelter Island New York NY 11944. Inns, Bed and Breakfasts, Resorts, Lodging including Shelter Island vacation packages. Shelter Island motels lodging accommodation - hotel reviews, visitor reviews, advice, guide, travel packages, Vacation Tourist, Info. / Tourist Information

Book a Flight

Find a Flight

Book It
Rent a Car

Find a Car

Rent It